Reading time:
6 min
How to find your investment solution in pillar 3a
Saving in pillar 3a is second nature for most people in Switzerland. However, if you're looking for the optimal investment strategy, it's easy to get lost in the jungle of rules of thumb, bank offers, and your own uncertainties. Thatโs why one of the most common questions from our customers is: ยซHow do I find the 3a investment strategy that really fits me?ยป Weโre bringing clarity to the topic and showing you the right approach to determine the matching equity ratio.
THE MOST IMPORTANT POINTS AT A GLANCE:
No standard formulas: Rules of thumb like ยซ100 minus ageยป are too rigid and ignore your personal situation.
Holistic view: Donโt view your pillar 3a in isolation, but as part of your overall financial planning.
Three decision factors: Your risk capacity (finances), your risk tolerance (mindset), and your investment goal determine your optimal investment strategy.
Index
Beware of unsuitable formulas
There are plenty of ยซwell-meant recommendationsยป. However, we advise against formulas that seem simple at first glance. A real evergreen is the rule: ยซEquity share = 100 minus your ageยป.
This rule falls short. It reduces a very important financial decision to a single factor: your age. Yet your lifestyle, your plans, as well as your family, professional, and financial situation are completely unique. Two people of the same age can have completely different prerequisites. In one case, the money will soon flow into a home purchase; in the other, it will stay invested for decades. A formula that treats both the same can't work for both. Plus, this rule would require you to adjust your investment strategy every single year.
So, what should you do?
Pillar 3a as part of your financial planning
Itโs not complicated, but it does take a bit of care. It all starts with analyzing your entire financial situation. Pillar 3a is an important building block in this process.
Take a systematic approach. First, set the foundation:
Your budget: Itโs not your income level that counts, but whatโs left at the end of the month. Keep irregular expenses like taxes, insurance, and vacations in mind. In our budget article, we show you how to pull it off.
Your investment amount: Get clarity. List your liquid assets (e.g., bank accounts) and deduct short-term debt as well as an emergency fund. Whatever is left, you can invest with peace of mind.
The following three steps will lead you to the right 3a investment strategy:
Your risk capacity: How much financial risk can you afford to take? The longer your investment horizon and the higher your net worth, the better you can ride out crises in the financial markets.
Your risk tolerance: How much risk do you want to take? This is about psychology: Can you sleep soundly when market prices temporarily fall?
Your investment goals: What goal are you pursuing with the money? Whether it's retirement, buying a home, or building wealth for your family, your goal determines the timeline.
The keyword is ยซyourยป, because this analysis looks different for everyone.
Three real-life examples
Nora (33): Works as a marketing specialist in a corporation and has a high savings rate. She pays the maximum pillar 3a amount every year and consistently invests her additional savings monthly in an ETF savings plan. Her pension fund assets are growing fast, and her emergency fund is fully set up. She will likely inherit her parents' home in the future thanks to their support. She plans to draw her 3a balance only at age 65 or later. Her money has plenty of time to grow.
Matthias (45): Runs a small craft business and supports his family. His emergency fund for unexpected events is filled. Now he is saving for a home and wants to buy a house in 3 years. For this, he plans to use half of his 3a balance. As an entrepreneur, he is used to business risks, but has little other wealth besides his company. He is interested in financial investments, understands the basic concepts, but has no stock market experience yet. He neglected his pension fund during the buildup phase of his business.
Isabelle (58): Works as a lawyer, has a high net worth, and a very solid pension fund, which she will draw as a pension. Her 3a funds have so far stayed in a savings account. She doesn't need this money for her living expenses in retirement and wants to pass it on to her children later. She describes herself as risk-averse and has avoided making investments so far.
ll three have clarified their budget and investment amount. So let's focus on determining the investment strategy.
Step 1: Risk capacity - What risks can you take?
The following questions will guide you:
How long is your investment horizon in pillar 3a?
Are you strictly dependent on an exact amount at a specific point in time?
How important is pillar 3a for your living expenses in old age?
What share of your total wealth does pillar 3a represent?
Here is how it looks for our three individuals:
Nora |
|---|
Investment horizon: > 30 years. |
Role: Important, but not the only retirement provision. |
Result: Very high risk capacity. She can easily weather market fluctuations. |
Matthias |
|---|
Investment horizon: Very short for 50% of the money (3 years due to home purchase) and 20 years for the rest. |
Role: Essential, both for the home purchase and retirement provision. |
Result: Not able to take risks for half of the money. |
Isabelle |
|---|
Investment horizon: Short until her retirement, but very long for the beneficiary children. |
Role: Not needed for living expenses. |
Result: Financially very high risk capacity. |
As a general rule: The higher your risk capacity and the longer your investment horizon, the higher your long-term return potential. Use our pension calculator to see how much your pillar 3a can grow until retirement.
Step 2: Risk tolerance - What risks do you want to take?
This is about your attitude toward risk:
Do you want to get the maximum out of your return opportunities?
Do you have experience with fluctuating financial markets?
Do you stay calm when your portfolio is temporarily down 20%?
Here is how it looks for our three individuals:
Nora |
|---|
Has experience with investing. Market setbacks don't bother her. |
Attitude: Ready for high risks. |
Matthias |
|---|
Has no stock market experience, but is interested in investing and views fluctuations as the "price for returns." Additionally: Knows business risks from his company. |
Attitude: Ready for risks. |
Isabelle |
|---|
Has avoided risks in life and has no experience with financial investments. Doesn't want to see deep loss phases. |
Attitude: Risk-averse. |
Step 3: Investment goals - What should your money achieve?
Be clear about what the money is intended for:
Is there a specific purpose (e.g., buying a house or retirement) and payout date (at 65 or earlier)?
Is the money intended for third parties (e.g., children or charitable organizations)?
For our three individuals, the following aspects are front and center:
Nora |
|---|
Goal: Maximum wealth accumulation for retirement far in the future. |
Matthias |
|---|
Goal: 50% short-term for home purchase, 50% long-term for retirement provision in 20 years. |
Isabelle |
|---|
Goal: Security and wealth transfer to the next generation. |
Finding the matching strategy
Only the combination of risk capacity, risk tolerance, and goal yields your optimal investment strategy. For our three examples, this means:
Nora: Plenty of time, high risk tolerance, and a long-term goal. Recommendation: A 3a investment solution with 100% equities for maximum return opportunities.
Matthias: Split situation. Recommendation: Half for the home purchase stays safely in the 3a interest account. The other half is invested long-term in a growth-oriented strategy with 80% equities. Since he has no pension fund, it's important that his investments in pillar 3a achieve a high return until retirement so he builds up retirement assets.
Isabelle: High financial risk capacity meets a strong need for safety. Recommendation: A balanced strategy with 60% equities. That way, the money benefits long-term for her children without the fluctuations being too extreme.
Take the time to answer these questions for yourself. Itโs totally worth it!
And if you have any uncertainties or want a second opinion: Just contact us. Weโre happy to support you in a non-binding consultation.







