Reading time:
12 min
A Surprising Investment Return Analysis - Pillar 3a
Why do you pay into pillar 3a? The most popular answer: To save taxes! Accordingly, many Swiss people don't just chase after presents during the Christmas season, but also scramble money together for a contribution to pillar 3a. The annual tax deduction is undoubtedly the most well-known advantage of pillar 3a, but in the long run, it is not the most powerful. What few people know: Used correctly, pillar 3a is probably the most efficient investment vehicle for you. If you start early and take advantage of tax-optimized funds and comprehensive tax exemptions, you will build up a fortune without lifting a finger.
THE MOST IMPORTANT POINTS AT A GLANCE:
Investing instead of saving: With stocks, you achieve a significantly higher yield in the long run than with a 3a account.
Compound interest is the real star: The biggest advantage is not the one-off tax deduction, but the compound interest effect on the saved tax money as well as the elimination of income, wealth, and withholding taxes.
Recipe for success for you: Start early, pay in the maximum amount in January, stagger across up to 5 custody accounts, stay disciplined and invested during turbulent market phases, and choose a low-cost provider.
Index
How to optimize your pillar 3a
The recipe for success is simple:
Start as early as possible: As soon as you have an income subject to AHV contributions (for details, see our post ยซUnder 25ยป), you should start saving for your future self, because ยซTime in the market beats market timingยป.
Make full use of the maximum amount: Take full advantage of your leeway. Adjust your standing order every two years to match the statutory increases in the maximum amount.
Stagger up to 5 custody accounts: This allows you to close them in a staggered manner over several years when you retire, paying significantly less capital withdrawal tax. For explanations, see our blog post ยซHow many pillar 3a portfolios make sense for you?ยป or go directly to our calculator.
Take advantage of retroactive payments (since 2026): Didn't make full use of the maximum amount in previous years? Since 2026, you can specifically fill gaps that have arisen since 2025. You can find out which rules apply and how best to proceed in our article ยซWhen retroactive 3a purchases are worthwhileยป.
Rely on investments instead of accounts: The interest rate on a 3a savings account is currently usually below 1% per year. In the long run, this hardly protects against inflation. Investments, especially equities, offer significantly higher return potential over the long term. To calculate this, use our pension calculator. Not sure which investment strategy to choose? Follow our tips in our post ยซHow to find your investment solution in pillar 3aยป.
Choose a high equity allocation: If you have a long investment horizon, you benefit from the return potential of the stock markets. Swiss equities have achieved an average annual return of approximately 7.7% since 1926, far more than bonds (3.9%), gold (3.5%) or savings accounts (2.1%).ยน
Stay disciplined: Price drops on stock exchanges are normal and inevitable. They are the ยซtests of courageยป you have to pass. Anyone who panics and sells during a crisis turns temporary paper losses into real losses. Stay invested and ignore crash prophets! The same applies when things are going well. See our article ยซInvesting despite all-time highsยป.
Pay in as early as January: Since stock markets rise in more calendar years than they fall in the long run, making a deposit at the start of the year pays off. In Switzerland, only 30 of the last 100 years recorded a negative annual return. This way, your capital benefits from return opportunities right from day one.
Choose a cheap, digital provider: Pay attention to two things: the lowest total costs and the use of tax-optimised index funds. The fewer fees you pay, the more of your returns you get to keep. Check out our post ยซPillar 3a providers comparedยป and use our calculator to do the maths yourself.
Withdraw the money in stages: Don't make a mistake right before the finish line. Close only one 3a custody account per year and withdraw money from your pension fund in a separate tax year. You can find more information in our blog post ยซHow many pillar 3a portfolios make sense?ยป.
ยน All return figures are based on Pictet and the Institute for Banking and Financial Planning. But heads up: past performance doesn't automatically guarantee future performance!
Why investing makes all the difference in the long run
If you only want to implement one of the recommendations above, take #5 to heart, because the difference between account savings and investments is huge.
Historically, the market compensates investors for the risk they take:
Stocks (high risk, high return): As a stock investor, you benefit directly from the continuous value creation of the world's best companies.
Account (minimal risk, minimal return): Balance in a 3a account is very safe as a privileged deposit. In return, however, you get barely more than the key interest rate of the Swiss National Bank.ยฒ
ยฒ You'll find more on this topic in the market report for Q3 2026.

Despite turbulent times (2008 financial crisis, 2020 Corona, 2022 Ukraine war), a pure stock strategy achieved an attractive average return over the past 20 years.
The difference between e.g. 7.6% (stocks) and 0.4% (account) since 2005 may seem manageable in a single year. In the long run, compound interest unfolds its full power: Starting with 1'000 francs in 2005 grew to almost 5'000 francs after a good 20 years โ on the account, however, to just under 1'100 francs.
Pillar 3a: The perfect investment vehicle
Is a 3a investment solution worth more than investing in free assets?
Let's meet Leon:
Place of residence: Aarau
Age: 20 years old (starts working on January 1)
Starting salary: CHF 70'000 / year
Goal: Build up maximum wealth by retirement at age 65.
Method: Maximize the benefits of pillar 3a as well as free assets (for calculation details, see info box below).ยณ
ยณ Our results confirm the previous research by Patrick Eugster (Patrick investiert) as well as Stefan Huser and Toni Brcina (Schweizer Finanzblog). We've refined their models with additional assumptions: for the 45-year period, we assume an increasing maximum amount (by 2% every 2 years) as well as an annually rising gross salary, and we've modeled the negative effects of un-reclaimed US withholding taxes in free assets.
Question 1: What gives you the most retirement assets at age 65?

Answer: Pillar 3a, with a lead of over 470'000 francs!
Question 2: How does this advantage for pillar 3a come about?

How we calculate
We try to give as realistic an estimate as possible. Nevertheless, some simplifying assumptions are necessary:
Gross salary development: 2% increase per year (starting at 70'000 francs at age 20).
Taxable income: Rough estimate taking into account social security deductions (AHV/ALV), BVG deductions, pillar 3a contribution, as well as professional expenses and insurance deductions.
Taxes: All tax rates for income, wealth, and capital withdrawal taxes are based on the effective tariffs for the calendar year 2025 for the residence of Aarau.
Savings amount: Maximum amount and 2% increase every 2 years.
Staggering custody accounts: In pillar 3a, 5 custody accounts are maintained step by step and built up to the same extent each year. In free assets, only one custody account is needed.
Investment timing: 1st banking day of the year (ยซin advanceยป).
Gross return on equities: 6.0% per year for a portfolio of 40% Swiss equities and 60% Global equities (70% of which are US equities). This is chosen conservatively in view of the long-term study by Pictet, which shows an average return of 7.7% p. a. for Swiss equities since 1926 (global studies by Dimson & Marsh show comparable values for other industrialized nations).
Dividend yield: Assumption of 1.5% per year (Swiss equities pay out approx. 2โ2.5%, global equities approx. 1โ1.5% p. a.). In pillar 3a, US withholding taxes on dividends are fully reclaimed; in free assets, 15% are lost.
Investment form: Use of tax-optimized index funds in pillar 3a vs. low-cost ETFs in free assets.
Pillar 3a fees (findependent): All-in management fees of 0.29% per year on invested assets. No ETF costs (TER) or other costs (see below).
Fees in free assets: Same level as in pillar 3a. We consider this fair, because if you set up an ETF savings plan, additional costs such as stock exchange fees & stamp duties, trading spreads, currency conversion fees, and ETF costs (TER) are added. On the other hand, you can save on custody fees and management fees, especially if you do it yourself.
Answer: You benefit from four factors (see graphic) that reinforce each other:
Exemption from US withholding taxes: With private investing or normal foreign ETFs, at least 15% of US dividends are lost through withholding taxes. Swiss 3a pension foundations can recover 100% of these using special withholding tax-exempt index funds. Providers using ETFs in pillar 3a do not have this advantage! This brings around 0.2% additional return per year, amounting to around 16'000 francs for Leon over 45 years.
No wealth taxes: In free assets, as the custody account value rises, Leon pays more wealth tax year after year (relevant from year 12). What starts small (initially a tax rate of 0.15%) becomes substantial in the final years at over 3'000 francs per year (0.33%). In pillar 3a, assets are completely exempt from wealth tax until payout. Savings for Leon: around 42'000 francs.
No income taxes on dividends: In a private custody account, dividends must be taxed as income every year. In pillar 3a, they flow back 100% tax-free into the custody account and are reinvested. A dividend yield of 1.5% means a return reduction of 0.3% per year. Savings: around 68'000 francs.
The super lever: Compound interest on annually saved taxes: Every year, Leon saves taxes through his 3a contribution. He doesn't hand this saved money over to the tax office; instead, he can let it work for him in pillar 3a. The compound interest effect on every single tax saving is the real ยซsecretยป. The first few years are especially important: As a 20-year-old, he achieves an initial tax saving of around 1'400 francs (marginal tax rate of 19.2% on his contribution), which he can then let work for 45 years. If he didn't use pillar 3a, he wouldn't have this deduction available to invest in free assets, but would send the amount to the tax office. Over 45 years, due to the compound interest effect on the sum of all annual tax savings at 6% market performance, a fabulous additional wealth of 380'000 francs is created!
Surprising: The capital withdrawal tax (131'000 francs), even when staggered across 5 custody accounts, exceeds the sum of annual tax savings (total 95'000 francs over all 45 years)! In other words: The entire ยซpainstakingly earnedยป tax savings over 45 years are completely ยซeaten upยป by the capital withdrawal tax at the end.
Frequently asked questions and special cases
Leon's example is a theoretical calculation model. So let's leave the ivory tower behind and answer the questions that are on your mind.
Is pillar 3a worth it even for smaller amounts?
Yes! Even if you only pay in half of the maximum amount, you benefit from compound interest on the tax deduction and tax-free dividends and wealth. The total advantage is simply lower at around 240'000 francs.
Is 3a investing still worth it at 40?
Absolutely. While the compound interest effect works for a shorter time (25 years), the tax advantage kicks in: Total direct tax savings clearly outweigh the later capital withdrawal tax. The total advantage is around 91'000 francs.
What about a 40% equity strategy?
Here too, pillar 3a clearly beats free securities savings with a difference of almost 274'000. The tax advantage is significant, though the compound interest effect is weaker.
Is pillar 3a on an account worth it?
Yes, purely tax-wise it's worth it compared to a savings account. But you leave huge return potential on the table, as the compound interest engine barely gets going without stocks. The total advantage of pillar 3a is around 117'000, with the tax advantage taking up the lion's share.
Is pillar 3a with only one custody account worth it?
Yes, it's still worth it. However, you give away around 20'000 francs over 45 years. The reason is tax progression: If you withdraw all capital in a single year, you pay over 177'000 francs in capital withdrawal tax. With five staggered custody accounts, you break this tax peak and keep more for yourself.
What changes if you live in a different canton?
The core statement doesn't change: Pillar 3a beats free assets everywhere in Switzerland. Since tax rates for income, wealth, and capital withdrawal vary from canton to canton (and partly from municipality to municipality), only the exact numbers shift. However, the principle โ compound interest on saved tax money and tax-free returns โ works strongly everywhere.
What happens if laws change?
Politicians can adjust the rules of the game (e.g. regarding capital withdrawal taxes). However, since pillar 3a is a cornerstone of private pension provision in Switzerland and highly popular, fundamental changes are rather unlikely. Even though higher taxes on capital withdrawals have been discussed in recent years, the compound interest advantage will likely remain over decades. All calculations are based on current law.
What is the biggest risk?
(Unfortunately) That's you, specifically if you stray from your plan. We calculate with 6% return per year for stocks. Unfortunately, you don't just get a number like that handed to you on a silver platter. Reality looks different. There are years with double-digit returns, and then every now and then a crisis hits where stock markets temporarily fall by 20% or more. View these moments as ยซtests of courageยป. Only if you pass them and stay disciplined will you be rewarded with a nice pension sum at the end.
What is the biggest drawback of pillar 3a?
The restricted availability: Your money is generally locked until 5 years before regular retirement age. Early withdrawal is only possible in a few statutory exceptional cases. Pillar 3a is therefore unsuitable for short-term savings goals or an emergency fund. For long-term retirement provision, however, this ยซlockยป is also an advantage: It protects you from impulse purchases and lets your capital work undisturbed for decades.
Conclusion
Pillar 3a is far more than a simple tax-saving trick at the end of the year. Combined with a suitable investment strategy and low fees, it is the most effective way to build wealth for your future.
Our tip: Always put your first savings intended for retirement into pillar 3a and follow our recipe for success.
Don't have a pillar 3a yet? Start now, digitally and hassle-free with findependent.
Got questions? Just get in touch with us. We're happy to support you in a non-binding personal consultation.







